ETF Copilot

How each score is calculated

ETF Copilot research team

Last updated 18 Nov 2026

Every fund carries four scores from 0 to 10: Growth, Value, Quality and Risk. Each one compares the fund with every one of the 1,363 funds we publish that has that score, and higher is better in all four. A score is a place on a 0 to 10 scale: 8 means the fund comes out ahead of about 80% of the funds that have that score, and Value averages four such places. On a fund page, each score's "?" also gives the fund's place within its own category.

Growth

What goes in: analysts' consensus forecasts for the fund's holdings, plus the fund's dividend yield. For most companies the forecast is EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation) two years ahead against the last twelve months, counted in proportion to how much of each company the fund owns. Banks and insurers enter at their own forecast growth in earnings, or else in sales, and other companies without a usable two-year EBITDA forecast at their own forecast growth rate. The yield is the holdings' own dividend yield, weighted by how much of the fund each holding is. Source: our data vendor's analyst estimates and company financials, refreshed each trading night. How it is weighed: the fund's expected growth plus yield is placed among every fund we publish that has one; more expected growth plus yield gives a higher score.

Value

What goes in: four valuation multiples for the fund, built up from its holdings: price to earnings and enterprise value to EBITDA, each on the last twelve months and on the next twelve months' forecasts. Source: our data vendor's company financials, analyst estimates and prices, refreshed each trading night. How it is weighed: each multiple is first compared with the same fund's own last 10 years, and the cheaper it is against its own past, the better. Each of those four readings is then placed among every fund that has it, and the four places are averaged with equal weight. A high Value score means a fund is cheap against its own history compared with how other funds sit against theirs; it does not mean the fund has the lowest multiples.

Quality

What goes in: how profitable the fund's holdings are, judged by the kind of business each one is. Banks, insurers and other financial companies are judged on return on equity; software, internet, IT services and media companies, which need little physical capital, on EBITDA margin; every other company on return on invested capital and EBITDA margin, with equal weight. Extreme readings are capped. Each company is compared only with the other held companies of its own kind, and the fund's Quality is the average of its companies' readings, weighted by how much of each it holds. Source: our data vendor's company financials, refreshed each trading night. How it is weighed: the fund's figure is placed among every fund we publish that has one; more profitable holdings give a higher score. Debt and other balance-sheet measures are not part of it.

Risk

What goes in: three readings from the fund's own price history. How much its weekly returns swung over the last three years counts for half. Its deepest fall from a peak in the last five years counts for 30%. The average of its five worst one-year falls in the last five years counts for 20%. Source: daily closing prices, adjusted for dividends and splits, refreshed each trading night. How it is weighed: each reading is compared with the middle of all funds, allowing for how spread out funds are, the three are combined in those proportions, and the result is placed among every fund we publish that has one. Smaller swings and shallower falls give a higher score, so higher means steadier. How much a fund has gained does not enter Risk.

Category place

On a fund page, each score's "?" gives where the fund stands within its own category, such as 3rd of 40. Funds in the category are ordered on the score as it is displayed, to one decimal; funds showing the same figure share a place, and funds without that score are left out of the count rather than put last. A category with fewer than five scored funds, and the non-equity group, get no place. The score itself is always placed among all funds, so a fund can sit high among all funds and middling in a strong category.

Ranked lists

Each ranked list blends past returns, these scores, fund size and concentration in its own proportions. A list first sets its entry rules, such as a fund-size band, a minimum trading volume, a cost ceiling and minimum scores, then orders the funds that pass by its blend, keeps the categories on the list varied, and lets in only one of a set of near-identical funds.

Missing data

A score is never estimated. A fund that lacks the inputs for a score shows no score for it and is left out of that score's comparison, rather than placed last. Value uses whichever of its four multiples the fund has, and a multiple counts only once the fund has a year of its own history and holdings that cover at least 40% of the fund. Risk uses the readings it has, in the same proportions. Quality needs companies with the figures making up at least half of the fund.

Coverage

The 1,363 funds we publish, which every score compares a fund with, include 46 funds we file as non-equity, such as preferred-stock, bond and loan, commodity, buffer and leveraged funds, which are scored alongside the rest but given no place within a category.

Data and freshness

Every score is rebuilt each US trading day after the market closes, from that day's closing prices, each fund's latest holdings list (usually the previous trading day's) and the company financials and analyst estimates our data vendor holds that night. The new board usually goes live between about 7:15 and 8 pm New York time, and later on a slow night; until then the site shows the previous trading day's board. There is no updating during the day.

Worked example: VOO, board of 18 Nov 2026

Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO)
ScoreVOOWhyIn its category
Quality8.4Its holdings are more profitable than those of about 84% of funds20th of 53
Growth7.7Analysts expect more growth plus yield for its holdings than for about 77% of funds22nd of 53
Risk6.8Its swings and past falls are smaller than for about 69% of funds24th of 53
Value3.6Its multiples sit near the middle of its own 10-year range, while most funds are cheaper against their own past39th of 52

Category: US Large Cap Blend. Each score is placed among the 1,363 funds ETF Copilot publishes.